Sunday, October 24, 2010

How Long After Va Appraisal Does It Take

[SCADA] SCADA Security ... or Not

I recently had the opportunity to work on SCADA environments: things change! But how? How to deal with these animals there? What are the most recurring faults? And already, is it secure? Petit point on my initial feedback.


What's being said on the Net

There are articles on the Net for some years now but on sites and blogs across the Atlantic and not in France. Yet there are major players in this country.

Having had the opportunity to work on the subject, one realizes that a SCADA pentest do not be approached in the same manner as a conventional web application for example. Why? Because in the case of a SCADA system is the availability that is required first and not the privacy of our dear banking applications or commercial.

Once we understand this, we better understand the vulnerabilities found as we hope above all that it works and whether it is effective where the attacker is likely to be faced with:
  • systems unpatched for months (... years);
  • access without a password;
  • files containing text or other identifiers;
  • unencrypted communications;
  • etc..
short, it seems that a SCADA pentest is simply out its panoply of hacker basis, ie:
  • MBSA scanner or another;
  • nmap, wireshark
  • ;
  • the search engine's operating system and
  • ultimate weapon, the enter key once on the field "password "
  • etc..

And what happens in real life

Well, let's be honest, I have not had the opportunity to do 50,000 tests on SCADA environments but this is what can I say I could see. Prior to frame the subject, you should know that the applications were installed on Windows servers and he must add to its methodology that a test of a heavy application. So when the attacks mentioned above does not work, we add to our range of decompiler and debuggers (I'll stop there, I am not a "pure donate";)).

pentest The first happened as was told on the Internet: namely that there was not safety. Finally, I'm exaggerating, there was a password. But it was teeeeeeeeeeeeellement complicated, I needed to help ...

... Then I looked at the help where it was written:

The default user name is "guest". The default password is "0".

So now if we get the solution, what will become of us;)

Well, it's done. At the same time, you'll tell me, it concerned only the password of an account "guest" so it's no big deal ... except that! In fact, it had granted the privileges strongest to this account ...

Another met a server where a missing Windows patches sixty ... When talking about viruses and worms, I can confirm that SCADAs are also concerned! And the damage, promising: /

Only not always so simple and I actually met a case where the passwords were strong flows and encrypted passwords were secured in a secure way. So, a SCADA security is possible! Except ... decompiler a (specific) was present on the server and it was therefore possible to create an account and to give higher privileges in passing ... BINGO!


tools every day, for testing SCADAS

This is not necessarily known, but the tools we use every days take into account SCADAS. And I can only quote the famous NESSUS offering a family named SCADA plugins are 42 plugins on the subject.


Metasploit also proposes a feat done everything for some SCADAs.



short, the means exist to control the security (and vice versa for the twist) of a SCADA system but already we have to fight sometimes to explain the benefits of security here, there is concern that the test Either already causing a disturbance and we must recognize that the financial impact is direct here. But it will he the day a SCADA network be infected? A SCADA system be targeted (and not necessarily by a seasoned striker!).

While we talk about war and digital energies (which control the SCADA) represent the hotspot of the war, the risk is very real and important. We already see what can cause a shortage of energy such as oil for a few days)

0 comments:

Post a Comment